Quotes

The Cry Wolf Quote Bank chronicles the false predictions and hyperbole by opponents of these laws and protections.  While the issues and specific policies change over time, the rhetoric and themes remained the same.  You can search the Quote Bank for what opponents said to prevent these laws from passing. Using the drop down menus on the right their statements by issue, by specific law, by who said it and by the core themes they evoke.   Elsewhere on the site, you can find articles, studies, and other material that debunks their claims. 

E.g., 2024-06-03
E.g., 2024-06-03

Being the only state to have absolute caps on carbon emissions puts California at a competitive disadvantage. [The legislation] will have little impact on global climate change but a severe negative impact on California's economy.

-
California Chamber of Commerce President Allan Zaremberg. Greenwire.
08/31/2006 | Full Details

If our manufacturers leave, whether for North Carolina or China, and they take their greenhouse gases with them, we might not have solved the problem but exacerbated it instead.

-
California Chamber of Commerce President Allan Zaremberg. Greenwire.
08/31/2006 | Full Details

Massachusetts cannot escape the new world order. As business across the nation resists being used as a government beast of burden, or run by its unions, it outsources jobs overseas to workers who are grateful to have them. Or hires illegal immigrants. Or begins to develop robots to take the place of entitled, demanding humans. Eventually, American ex-workers will have lots of free time to hang out with their families, though the money to feed, shelter and clothe them may be in short supply.

-
Barbara Anderson, executive director of Citizens for Limited Taxation, The Providence Journal.
05/05/2006 | Full Details

This is either a late April Fool's Day joke or Massachusetts should be on suicide watch….Here we are, one of only two states to lose population; sixth-highest tax burden; national reputation for high cost of doing business….Yes, along with our winter weather and everything else that discourages job creation here, we would have the 'most generous' mandatory paid leave in the country. Eventually, of course, the new employee tax would increase and be joined by a new tax on employers.

-
Barbara Anderson, executive director of Citizens for Limited Taxation, The Providence Journal.
05/05/2006 | Full Details

The proposal is couched in the soothing and smarmy rhetoric of leftist populism….But if that's all it takes, why stop there? If a simple legislative act increasing the minimum wage to $7.75 is all that is needed to improve the lot of the working poor by just a little, then why not raise it to $10 an hour and get them to the poverty level? For that matter, why not raise it to $50 an hour, assuring every working Californian a comfortable living?

-
Tom McClintock, California Republican state senator. “The Los Angeles Times.
04/11/2006 | Full Details

The truth is that if your labor is worth $6.75 an hour and the minimum wage is raised to $7.75, you simply become unemployable. The first rung of the ladder is gone, and there's no place to start….This legislation is the ultimate expression of the cruelest of all human lies: ‘I'm from the government, and I'm here to help.'

-
Tom McClintock, California Republican state senator. The Los Angeles Times.
04/11/2006 | Full Details

We firmly believe behavior modification and training are the keys to ensure miners know and want to do their work in a safe manner.

-
Bill K. Caylor, president of the Kentucky Coal Association. Op-ed, Louisville Courier-Journal.
02/05/2006 | Full Details

But the governors of Connecticut, Delaware, Maine, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York and Vermont are still in the compact, ready to impose a heavy economic burden on their citizens.

-
From “Ungreening Mitt Romney”, by Robert Novak.
01/02/2006 | Full Details

Everybody agrees that carbon limits will force up electricity prices steadily far into the future. The disagreement is over how much the costs will go up….That is unnerving for Massachusetts, which now has the nation's highest electric power bills. However, the bigger impact could be on the cost to industries that threatens the loss of jobs.

-
From “Ungreening Mitt Romney”, by Robert Novak.
01/02/2006 | Full Details

While the states signing on the dotted line will trumpet this proposal, the economic reality ... ought to be a bucket of icy cold New England water. [Now consumers will be] paying even higher prices.

-
Frank Maisano, a utility industry lobbyist with Bracewell & Giuliani in Washington.
12/22/2005 | Full Details

Pages